cervical cancer malpractice, failure to diagnose, error, statute of limitations, cervical cancer malpractice. 

Cummins v. Marchetti, No. CA 04-02775 (N.Y.App.Div. 04/29/2005)

Plaintiffs commenced this medical malpractice action seeking damages for the misdiagnosis of a tissue sample sent by the treating gynecologist of Judith Cummins (plaintiff), David L. Marchetti, M.D., to defendant Quest Diagnostics, Inc., (Quest). Defendant Peter Vasilion, M.D., a pathologist and employee of Quest, reported that the tissue sample was not indicative of cervical cancer. The sample was re-read by Vasilion at the request of Marchetti after plaintiff's cancer was diagnosed and treatment was commenced.

Supreme Court erred in denying the motions of Quest and Vasilion to dismiss the complaint as untimely pursuant to CPLR 214-a. Plaintiffs commenced this action more than two years and six months after the alleged misdiagnosis by Quest and Vasilion, and the re-reading of the tissue sample by Vasilion for purposes other than diagnosis or treatment did not implicate the continuous treatment doctrine and toll the statute of limitations with respect to Quest and Vasilion (see McDermott v Torre, 56 NY2d 399, 407-408; Waring v Kingston Diagnostic Radiology Ctr., 13 AD3d 1024, 1026).


Hit Counter


Contact Information

Howard A. Gutman, Esq.
230 Route 206,  Building 3
Flanders, New Jersey 07836, 
New York Office

305 Madison Avenue, Suite 449,

New York, New York 10165

Lung Cancer and Mesothelioma 

Quality Books "This book provides an invaluable resource for anyone who has or who is caring others with Mesothelioma or other Lung cancers. It provides a wealth of relevant and useful information on various types of lung cancers, medical trials, treatments and medications. This well researched and comprehensive book is quite unique on the subject. This book also contains a detailed discussion on the emotional burden of Lung Cancer upon the patient and their families and ways to manage it."

keywords cervical cancer malpractice, statute of limitations, failure to diagnose, error, statute of limitations, medical malpractice, delayed diagnosis of cancer, missed diagnosis, cervical cancer screening,  pelvic pain, pelvic discomfort, , pathology, medical error and cervical cancer, missed diagnosis of cervical cancer,  pap smear, misinterpretation of pap smear, cervical cancer malpractice.